Salta al contenuto principale


Proposal to drop the letter J from English.

It is the letter with the biggest identity crisis.

Jelly - sounds like a soft G
Jalapeño - sounds like an H
Juanita - sounds like a W
Ja - (ok this is germanic, but still) - sounds like a Y

It really is a pointless letter.

in reply to David de Groot

I think writing my wife's name as Gennifer just looks very wrong. J is a prettier letter. YMMV.

How about we get rid of soft G's? Edj, sludj, jiraffe, gauj, ajitate.

in reply to lutoma

@lutoma I was all good with reading that example until the last line. (Although it *looked* very dutch/germanic at first glance, while not being anything like either).
in reply to David de Groot

Unless your name is Jasper, Jay or Jack or John, or if you drink juice.
in reply to David de Groot

There's no J in the traditional Welsh alphabet, but even we knew enough to borrow the damn thing (Jones, Jenkins, etc).
in reply to David de Groot

@David de Groot @Tris Kerslake surely you mean sukko (the Italian word for juice in most cases would be succo, but since you all want to also get rid of Cs…)
in reply to David de Groot

@David de Groot @Tris Kerslake not that there is really a difference between G and C, back in *my* time¹ you'd just have C and you just knew how to pronounce it!

¹ why think about the Roman empire when you can think about the Roman *kingdom*² :D

² or early republic, wikipedia tells me that G was added probably in the 3rd century BC

Oblomov reshared this.

in reply to David de Groot

Within English vocab though, it's pretty consistent as to pronunciation (two of the words you mention are really Spanish words). I'd take a long hard look at C, whose sounds can be done by other existing letters:

Coat - sounds like K
Cellophane - sounds like S

Not to mention the three types of sound "ch" makes. :)

in reply to Tim Richards

@timrichards Well yes, I have opinions about C as well, either that or K (as the newcomer compared with C).
in reply to David de Groot

At least K is Konsistent. ;) Frankly we could ditch Q and X too, superfluous.

Questo sito utilizza cookie per riconosce gli utenti loggati e quelli che tornano a visitare. Proseguendo la navigazione su questo sito, accetti l'utilizzo di questi cookie.